Every study here has its own page: the idea, what we tested, headline numbers, and why it died. Each cause of death is explained on how we test.

Didn't work

Idea Family Cause of death Headline
144 signal tests Diagnostics Overfit Two small "winners"; largest effect inside the noise (p = 0.22)
1,192 indicator combinations Models Overfit Best Sharpe 0.74; scrambled-data searches usually did better (p = 0.73)
Weekly reversal Reversal Edge decayed Train Sharpe 0.69; validation Sharpe 0.02–0.11 vs SPY 0.92
32 trend variants Trend Overfit Best Sharpe 0.70, drawdown 5%; overfitting probability 0.62
Plain 200-day rule Trend Works but not worth it Halved the drop in 2022–23; failed its bar in 2017–21
Turn of the month Calendar Works but not worth it Invested 12% of the time, 3.8% a year
Pre-Fed-announcement drift Calendar Not tradable The gain was overnight, before our fill
Turn of month plus Fed days Calendar Works but not worth it Failed both windows
Volatility-targeted SPY/VTI/VUG Volatility Works but not worth it Sharpe 0.89 vs SPY 0.92 in 2017–21
Yield-curve alarm Macro Edge decayed 7% invested in 2022–23
Moon phases Esoteric Edge decayed New moon lost to full moon in 2017–21
24 "conditions align" setups Setups Overfit 0 of 24 survived
28 indicator families and pairs Models Overfit Best Sharpe 0.62; deflated Sharpe 0.943 vs bar 0.95
Machine-learning models on 24 indicators Models Overfit No better than models trained on shuffled data
A take-or-skip judge Models Works but not worth it Approved nearly every signal

Passed, with heavy caveats

Idea Family Label Headline
The drawdown brake Trend + volatility Passed, unproven live Passed 6 of 7 new market groups; gives up much of the return. Read the caveats first.

Couldn't be tested

Idea Family Why
The Benner cycle (1875) Esoteric About 21 years of daily data cannot test a chart that makes a handful of calls

On the list

Not run yet: Wilder's Delta Phenomenon, as soon as we can code its rules as published. When it runs, it gets a page here whether it works or not.

Trial counts and rules are on each page. Everything is based on public data (see about).