Moon phases: new moon beat full moon in one window and lost in the other

· 1 min read

Failure type: edge decayed. Verdict: failed 2017–2021, passed 2022–2023, not confirmed. Family parked.

The idea

Two published papers report returns that differ around new and full moons (Dichev and Janes, 2003; Yuan, Zheng and Zhu, 2006). The test: are average SPY returns higher around new moons than around full moons? We computed phases from Meeus, Astronomical Algorithms (1998).

What happened

Average daily excess return New moon Full moon Result
2017–2021 0.063% 0.069% Fail (wrong sign)
2022–2023 0.045% −0.025% Pass

An executable version (hold SPY at 75% on the favorable days) returned a Sharpe of 0.42 in 2017–2021 and 0.17 in 2022–2023.

Why it failed

The sign flipped between windows. It was one pre-registered test per window, not a search, and a rule with no real effect passes any given window about half the time. We parked lunar, Gann and Bradley-style timing as a family.

Receipts: the test was pre-registered before the run.

Research and education only. These are paper results from historical data on a limited set of funds. Not investment advice, not a recommendation, not a prediction. See Legal.