What survived
One thing so far cleared its pre-registered tests: a 200-day trend filter with a 10% volatility target that we call the drawdown brake. It is the opposite of a winning system. Here's why you shouldn't get excited:
- It is a brake, not an engine. It cut the worst drop in all seven new market groups we tried, but it usually gave up return. In crypto it earned 28% a year against 101% for buy-and-hold. In the strong 2017–2021 stock market it earned about 8% a year against SPY's 18%.
- It failed the batch-level overfitting check. It was confirmed under its own pre-registered rule, not by clearing the deflated-Sharpe bar across the batch it came from.
- It missed one of seven groups (country ETFs, by 0.008 of Sharpe) and we left that as a miss.
- It is paper only. No real money has used it. Costs and fills are simulated.
- The samples are friendly or short. Crypto is a few boom-heavy years. The 2022–2023 window is about 480 trading sessions.
Read the full write-up, with the market-by-market table.
If it ever does well with real money, we'll say so here. If it doesn't, it moves to the graveyard.
Research and education only. Not investment advice. See Legal.