The drawdown brake: passed on paper, not proven with money
Failure type: none yet. Label: passed on paper, not proven with real money.
The idea
Hold each fund only while its price is above its 200-day average, and cash otherwise. Then scale the whole book down when recent volatility is high, so the portfolio aims for about 10% yearly volatility. We call it the drawdown brake. Volatility-managed portfolios have published support (Moreira and Muir, Journal of Finance, 2017). The 200-day filter is a classic trend rule.
What we did
- Rule written first, never tuned. 200-day average, monthly (every 21 sessions) check, 10% volatility target from the prior month's realized volatility, no leverage.
- Original test: 23 ETFs, two windows chosen in advance: 2017–2021 and 2022–2023. It was one of seven strategies in a single pre-registered batch (15 official trials).
- Out-of-sample test: the same rule, unchanged, on seven groups of markets it was never tuned on: commodity ETFs, bond ETFs, real-estate ETFs, country ETFs, currency ETFs, four large crypto assets, and six major currency pairs. Pass rule written in advance: Sharpe at least that of equal-weight buy-and-hold, and worst drop at most 60% of buy-and-hold's. Confirmed if at least 4 of 7 groups pass.
What happened
On the original ETFs it edged out the plain 200-day rule: Sharpe 1.00 against 0.97 in 2017–2021, worst drop 11.3% against 13.4%. In 2022–2023 it was about even (Sharpe −0.03 against −0.05).
Across the seven new groups it passed 6 of 7:
| Market group | Sharpe, brake vs hold | Worst drop, brake vs hold | Yearly return, brake vs hold | Average invested |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Commodities | 0.28 vs 0.01 | 24% vs 68% | 3.0% vs 0.0% | 31% |
| Bonds | 0.49 vs 0.42 | 10% vs 20% | 2.8% vs 3.7% | 48% |
| Real estate | 0.36 vs 0.21 | 11% vs 51% | 3.4% vs 3.3% | 31% |
| Countries | 0.29 vs 0.29 (missed by 0.008) | 23% vs 61% | 3.6% vs 5.6% | 48% |
| Currency ETFs | 0.14 vs −0.58 | 5% vs 13% | 1.5% vs 0.0% | 28% |
| Crypto | 1.55 vs 1.24 | 23% vs 88% | 28% vs 101% | 17% |
| Currency pairs | −0.12 vs −0.22 | 15% vs 34% | 0.8% vs −0.5% | 49% |
Read this part carefully
- It is a brake, not an engine. In the strong 2017–2021 stock market it earned about 8% a year against 18% for plain SPY. In crypto it earned 28% a year against 101% for buy-and-hold, because it was invested only 17% of the time.
- It still fails the batch-level overfitting check. The deflated Sharpe across the batch was 0.78 for 2017–2021 and 0.40 for 2022–2023, against a 0.95 bar. The idea was confirmed under its own pre-registered rule, not by clearing that check.
- Countries missed. We did not move the line to make it 7 of 7.
- Short, friendly samples. Crypto history here is roughly 2016 to 2023, a period of enormous growth. The 2022–2023 stock window is about 480 sessions, too short to say much.
- Paper only. Simulated fills and costs. No real money has used it. Prices come from free data and the fund list is not survivorship-free.
- Not advice. Do not read this page as a reason to buy anything.
Receipts: the rule and pass criteria were written down and committed before the batch ran, and again before the cross-market test. The data for 2024 onward was not used.
Research and education only. These are paper results from historical data on a limited set of funds. Not investment advice, not a recommendation, not a prediction. See Legal.