A take-or-skip judge on top of our setups: it took nearly everything
Failure type: works but not worth it. Verdict: no trigger set passed.
The idea
Meta-labeling: don't ask a model to predict prices, ask whether a given signal is worth acting on. We applied this to three signals: the deep-pullback setup, the calming-volatility setup, and 200-day overlay turn-on events. Conditions were rendered as simple labels (up, flat, down) for a fixed-choice decision gate (JJM).
What happened
The gate can't yet accept a chronological holdout (it holds out a random 20%), so reported numbers use a plain logistic-regression stand-in trained on the same labels. It took 100% of the pullback and overlay events and 79% of the calming-volatility events. For the one setup where it skipped anything, taken events were not significantly better than skipped (p = 0.27).
Why it failed
A filter that says yes to nearly everything doesn't filter. A numeric baseline on raw z-scores was specified and not run. We did not reopen it.
Receipts: the plan was written down and committed first.
Research and education only. These are paper results from historical data on a limited set of funds. Not investment advice, not a recommendation, not a prediction. See Legal.