Receipts for the strategies that failed
Trading strategies that didn't work, with the receipts.
Receipts for the strategies that failed.
Most trading sites sell the thing that supposedly works. This one publishes the things that didn't: each idea's rules written down before the test, how many tries it took, how it did in more than one window and market, and a plain verdict on why it failed.
Research and education only. Not investment advice. Findings are derived from public data.
Weekly reversal: buy the most oversold ETFs and hold a few weeks. Numbers from the write-up; this is paper research, not a recommendation.
The pitch Buy the bounce
Rank the 23 ETFs by 5-day return or 2-day RSI, hold the three or five most oversold, and rebalance every 5 or 10 sessions.
What happened The training years loved it
On 2005–2016 the best variant had Sharpe 0.69 against 0.40 for SPY, with a 15.6% worst drop against 55.2%.
On the pre-registered 2017–2021 window, no variant passed: Sharpe 0.02–0.11 against SPY's 0.92, and about 0–1.5% a year against 18.3%.
Verdict Edge decayed
Costs were not the cause: with zero costs the best Sharpe was only 0.144. The family is parked. We did not re-tune on the validation years.
How things die
What is overfitting? Fitting a strategy so closely to the past that it mostly captures noise, then watching it fall apart on new data. See Investopedia’s explainer (external), or how we test.
| Cause of death | What it means |
|---|---|
| Overfit | The winner doesn't survive an honest count of how many things we tried, or it's no better than scrambled data. |
| Not tradable | The effect may be real but we couldn't have captured it with realistic trading rules. |
| Edge decayed | It worked in one period and failed a later window we fixed in advance. |
| Works but not worth it | It does something real, but misses its bar or gives up the whole return. |
| Passed, unproven live | It cleared its pre-registered tests. It has not been proven with real money. |
Recently buried
Overfit
144 signal tests, two winners, no edge
Overfit
1,192 indicator combinations: the winner was no better than luck
Edge decayed
Weekly reversal: great on 2005–2016, nothing on 2017–2021
Not tradable
Pre-Fed-announcement drift: real, but it happens overnight
Overfit
Wait for the stars to align: 24 setups, 0 survivors
Research and education only. Not investment advice, not a recommendation to buy or sell anything. Overfit is a product of Catalyst Forge, LLC.